Letter from Glasgow
To cite: Kohli HS. Letter from Glasgow. Natl Med J India 2021;34:241–2.
CLIMATE CHANGE AND HEALTH
Fifty years is a long time ago but I remember 1971 very well. I was 14 years old and having left India aged 5 for Scotland, I went back to India for the first time since leaving. I spent 2 months that glorious summer visiting relatives and having a great holiday visiting Delhi, Amritsar, Dehradun, Agra and Mumbai, among other places.
In the history of climate change, 1971 was also the year that the Study of Man’s Impact on Climate conference of leading scientists reported a danger of global climate change caused by humans.1 Ominously, it was also reported that the Mariner 9 spacecraft found a great dust storm warming the atmosphere of Mars, with indications that Mars had a different climate in the past.
What I do not remember in 1971 is a young man, John Forbes Kerry, who had served in the US Army in Vietnam.2 He came back from the war to become a spokesperson for the Vietnam Veterans Against the War. It was many years later I saw his testimony on 22 April 1971 at the hearing on the Vietnam War of the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee. His testimony is electrifying in its ‘telling truth to power’ of the lies told about US intervention in Vietnam.3,4 If you have not heard the speech, do so and feel the hair on your neck stand on end.
Why, I hear you say, is he wittering on (an informal UK term for speaking at length about trivial matters) about 1971, climate change, John Kerry and the Vietnam War? And what has this to do with public health? But bear with me.
John Kerry is now a seasoned American politician and diplomat and is currently serving as the first United States Special Presidential Envoy for Climate. He will be coming to Glasgow for COP26, the UN Climate Change Conference UK 2021, in November.5 John Kerry has carved out an interest in climate change and has a passion for the urgent need to act. He has stated: ‘Climate change, if unchecked, is an urgent threat to health, food supplies, biodiversity, and livelihoods across the globe.’ The COP26 conference will bring together governments and non-governmental organizations to agree action to achieve the goals of the Paris Agreement and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. If ever there is a need for governments around the world to face the truth on climate change, then having John Kerry on your side is a good start.
Depending on how the pandemic behaves, around 30 000 delegates from 196 countries could attend COP26 in Glasgow. Let’s just hope it does not become a Covid-19 superspreader event because so much is at stake. For public health, it is important because the consequences of climate change are profound, and my sense is that health professionals have been a little slow in recognizing the urgency of the situation and the impact on health.
For the avoidance of doubt, climate change is the result of greenhouse gas emissions caused by human activities.6 Historically, high-income countries benefited from these emissions and of course, now as low- and middle-income countries try and join the industrialization and urbanization party, we are faced with stark choices of having to limit greenhouse gas emissions. Changes to climate are already ‘wired in’, and how much we restrict emissions will influence how much the global temperature rises. The UK is already experiencing change with a warmer, sunnier and wetter climate.7 Globally, these effects will be magnified and the Maldives face an existential threat.
Public health has highlighted the problems of climate change. For example, in The future public health, Hanlon et al. argued for public health to rise to the challenge of the collision of the environment and the economy and achieve sustainability.8 However, we need to do much more, and soon. In the UK, the direct health impacts of climate change include ‘…changing exposure to heat and cold, increased exposure to UV radiation, air pollution, pollen, emerging infections, flooding and associated water-borne diseases and the impact of extreme weather events such as storms and floods, notably on mental health’.9 In addition, there are indirect effects of climate change on peoples’ jobs, and water, food and energy availability.
The title of the Institute of Health Equity report is instructive—‘Sustainable Health Equity: Achieving a Net Zero UK’.9 As you would expect with research associated with Michael Marmot, it is rigorous, is evidence-based, is thoughtful and focuses on health equity. It reinforces the point that climate change is already damaging the British population and highlights the direct and indirect pathways of health effects from climate change. The report is optimistic, arguing that climate change actions could improve health and health equity. However, that requires political and policy commitment, a clear strategic, operational plan and funding. There is a real danger that we accept the attitude that ‘there is nothing we can do about climate change’ and miss the opportunities that we still have to mitigate its effects. The report counters that by advocating practical and realistic changes in five key areas for health and climate change: a just energy policy that minimizes air pollution; designing and retrofitting homes to be energy-efficient, climate-resilient and healthy; building a sustainable and healthy food system; developing a transport system that promotes active travel and road safety, and which minimizes air pollution; and developing healthy and sustainable models of work.
I welcome John Kerry and COP26 coming to Glasgow, even if I am a little apprehensive––about the pandemic not being over yet, and that we need to act more decisively to counter climate change and its health effects. COP26 has a huge task ahead of it. It does not matter if you live in low-, middle- or high-income countries, what religion predominates in your society, whether it is a democratic or autocratic political system in your country or whether a country has a largely rural or largely urban-based population, all countries will be affected. As usual in any crisis, health or otherwise, it is likely that poorer countries and poorer people in all countries will suffer disproportionately. So, it will be with climate change and they will face severe health (and economic and social) effects unless we can act globally and collectively in a fair and equitable way, allowing sustainable development. Let’s hope John Kerry’s history of talking truth to power helps at COP26 and encourages countries, finally, to act boldly and firmly for the health of people everywhere.
Conflicts of interest
I am a non-executive director of the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA https://www.sepa.org.uk/). SEPA is Scotland’s principal environmental regulator, protecting and improving Scotland’s environment.
- The history of climate change. Available at www.livescience.com/1292-history-climate-change-science.html (accessed on 30 Jul 2021)
- [Google Scholar]
- COP26-UN Climate Change Conference UK 2021.
- Available at www.theccc.org.uk/what-is-climate-change/ (accessed on 30 Jul 2021)
- The future public health. Maidenhead: Open University Press;
- [Google Scholar]
- Institute of Health Equity. 2020. Available at www.theccc.org.uk/publication/ucl-sustainable-health-equity-achieving-a-net-zero-uk/ (accessed on 30 Jul 2021)
- [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]